THE REDWOOD JOURNAL
VOLUME:-1 ISSUE NO:- 1 , DECEMBER 7, 2025
Website: www.theredwoodjournal.com
Email: theredwoodjournal@gmail.com
Authored by:- Dr.P.G.Sunanda Bhagavathy, Professor & Head, Department of Criminology, Karunya Institute of Technology and Sciences, Coimbatore,
Co Authored by:- R.Monica, Research Scholar, Karunya Institute of Technology and Sciences, Coimbatore
Abstract
It is saddening to note that as per the data available, this decade has witnessed a shocking rise in all Crimes, especially the juvenile crimes. However, the question is about the correctional facilities and the moral values parents and society are inculcating in young minds, whether it is a boon or a bane? Where are they lagging? The molding part of a child rests in the hands of parents and educational institutions as they spend most of the time either with the educational institution or with the family. Are they doing their molding part properly? And correctional institutions that are supposed to protect, rehabilitate, and restore the life of a juvenile delinquent sometimes are becoming a nightmare for them. Juveniles are the ones who are being victimized in all walks of life. Many are subjected to physical and sexual exploitation and mental trauma and the prime intention behind the creation of such correctional facilities are defeated. Considering a country where the young ones form part of 1/3rd of its total population, one would wonder whether they are capable enough to deal with juvenile delinquents. With this question starts the blaming game where parents, educational institutions and correctional institutions try to shift the baton to one another for the increased crime rate. The plight of juveniles is that in spite of these many facilities, they still are the victims of anomalies. It is a shame they are directly victimized because of the faulty system. As the juvenile crime rate rises, it alarms the society to foresee the future nation and it is time for action instead of reaction. This paper here is an introspection of the flaws of family, society and institutions and suggestions to improve the conditions in existence.
Key words: Victimization, Juvenile Delinquency, Rehabilitation, Protection, Institutional flaws, Child in need of care & protection.
Page 1
Introduction:
“Child is the incarnation of divinity. Its innocence and smile are its greatest and enchanted virtues which can dazzle and hypnotize even a person endowed with a heart of stone” [1]. Statistics show that about 19% of the world’s children live in India [2]. In a country that views children as future workers, juvenile delinquency is a major concern. This issue, affecting societies globally, highlights the need for extensive care. Despite protective measures, children’s vulnerability can still lead to deviant behavior [3].
JUVENILE CRIME RATE IN TAMILNADU:
According to NCRB’s CRIME IN INDIA 2020 report, there were 5,974 cases registered /filed against juveniles for which 7,475 juveniles were detained. Among those 7,475 juveniles detained, 6,774 were detained under IPC and 701 under SLL cases in 2020 and totally 5,644 juveniles which means 75.5% belong to the age group of 16-18. When we consider the states in India that has highest charge sheeting rate under IPC crimes, Tamil Nadu is in third place with 91.7% and in metropolitan cities Coimbatore is in the second place with 96.6% [4].
LITERACY RATE OF CHILDREN IN CONFLICT WITH LAW:
In TamilNadu of 3,843 juveniles detained only 60 are illiterates, whereas 712 juveniles had up to primary education, 2339 juveniles had up to matric education, 487 had education above matric and 245 studied above higher secondary. This statistics clearly shows that almost 99% of juveniles had at least up to matric level education that questions the moral and value education being taught in the schools [4].
FAMILY BACKGROUND OF JUVENILE DELINQUENTS:
Again if we take into consideration the family background of those 3,843 juveniles, 3,588 were living with their parents, 170 were living with their guardian and only 85 were homeless. These data depicts the listlessness of parents towards their off springs [4].
REVIEW OF LITERATURE:
A Hindustan Times article from December 19, 2023, notes that about 40% of young offenders live in conditions as harsh as, or worse than, adult prisons. A committee led by Judge Madan B Lokur, appointed by the Supreme Court, found similar poor conditions in government facilities, highlighting inadequate resources and accountability. [5].
Pushpender & Sabharwal.D (2023) [6] in their study titled, “Juvenile Delinquency in India : A Sociological study” discusses about the hike in rate of juvenile delinquency in India where they furthermore opines that providing education alone cannot reduce crime rate among juveniles as most of the young ones detained were educated [6].
Dr. Bhardwaj, Ramesh kumar &Neeraj (2021) in their study “Juvenile Delinquency in India- a study”, aims at studying the prevalence and the incidence of juvenile delinquency, the family background of those juveniles and their literacy rate in the states of India, especially in Haryana[7].
This piece of article in the swaddle dated December 14, 2021 discusses the flaws in India’s juvenile system where children are criminalized for their circumstances[8].
This article in Bharat Times dated September 27, 2021 talks about the double the rate of murder with minors in 5 years in Tamil Nadu [9].
One of the news article in Times of India dated 15-03-2021 reports about the escape of six juvenile offenders from the observation home, Coimbatore [10].
J.Jayabharath & Mrs. V.Udayavani (2018) in their study, “Case study on juvenile homes”, focuses on the impact of media, peer pressure, financial profile and the lack of socialization on the behaviour of 50 juveniles in the government observation home at Rourkela sub jail, Odisha through case study method [11].
Feroze ahmed (2016) in his study, “To study the juveniles of observation homes in Chennai – a case study”, explains about the impact of observation homes in the lives of juvenile delinquents, the administrative challenges faced by them and the role of society in educating and controlling them [12].
Devarmani (2016) in his research work “Institutional treatment for juveniles in India” discusses the prominence and the availability of institutional and non institutional correctional forums for juveniles as the need of the hour [13].
In this piece of article in The Hindustan Times dated July 11, 2016 was published the incident of escape of 33 juvenile inmates from Chennai observation home [14].
One of the news article in India.com dated September 16, 2016 talks about the instances where harassment took place in juvenile shelter homes in India [15].
Kunjana Mittal (2015) in her study “Juvenile delinquency in India”, discusses about the hike in juvenile crime rate in India, the laws pertaining to juvenile justice and also the changes in the Juvenile Justice (care and protection) Act 2000 [16].
EVOLUTION OF JUVENILE JUSTICE LAW IN INDIA
JUVENILE JUSTICE ACT, 2015
Figure 1: Juveniles of age group 16-18 yrs detained in 2020
Figure 2 : Literacy rate of Juvenile delinquents
Page 3
Figure 3 : Family Background of Juvenile delinquents
Historically, there was no specific age limit for juvenile delinquents. However, significant changes occurred when India faced widespread destruction and industry collapse due to British administrative failures. This turmoil led to a sharp rise in juvenile crime, prompting urgent reform.
In response to petitions from Jai Krishna Chandra Goshal and Jai Narayan Ghoshal, the Governor-General of India established a juvenile home in Kolkata in 1843. Seven years later, the Apprentices Act of 1850 was amended to include children aged 10-18 in the legal system, mandating correctional facilities that provided vocational training and moral guidance for convicted juveniles.
Further advancements came with the Reformatory School Acts of 1876 and 1897, which allowed courts to confine juvenile delinquents, under 18 years old, in correctional facilities for 2-7 years. The laws were later updated to include separate legal procedures for those under 15. Significant improvements in correctional facilities began with The Bombay Children Act of 1924, and the establishment of the Children’s Aid Society the same year.
In 1986, the Juvenile Justice Act reformed existing laws, though its implementation faced delays due to infrastructure issues. The Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2000, and its 2001 amendment raised the age limit for juveniles from 16 to 18 and introduced a National Level Advisory Board for better guidance.
By 2015, recognizing the evolving nature of juvenile crime, the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015, was enacted, allowing 16-18-year-olds to be tried as adults for severe crimes [17].
The Juvenile Justice Act of 2000 (Care and Protection) [17] is distinctive in clearly delineating between vulnerable children and those in conflict with the law. This differentiation was specifically introduced to address the growing number of violent children. Contrary to labeling them as offenders, the act characterizes these children as individuals struggling to adhere to the law. Consequently, the Juvenile Justice Board, rather than a Juvenile Court, is established under this act. Additionally, the legislation introduces a juvenile police unit, mandating each police station to designate at least one child-friendly officer capable of handling children in conflict with the law.
Previously overlooked, the act now includes children who are victims of armed conflict, civil unrest, and natural disasters in the category of those in need of care and protection.
The act classifies offenses into three categories: petty, serious, and heinous. Petty offenses are those punishable with imprisonment of up to three years, serious offenses involve punishments of 3 to 7 years, and heinous offenses encompass crimes punishable with seven or more years.
In essence, the act pertains to the apprehension, detention, prosecution, penalty, rehabilitation, and social reintegration of children facing challenges in complying with the law.
NOTABLE AMENDMENT TO THE JUVENILE JUSTICE ACT 2015
CHALLENGES OF JUVENILE JUSTICE ACT 2015
Page 3
JUVENILE JUSTICE ACT- A BOON
JUVENILE DELINQUENCY:
WHAT CAUSES JUVENILE DELINQUENCY?
INDIVIDUAL FACTORS:
FAMILY FACTORS:
ECONOMICAL FACTOR:
DRUG ABUSE:
CULTURAL CONFLICTS:
TYPES OF CORRECTIONAL FACILITIES IN INDIA
Page 4
SUGGESTIONS TO IMPROVE CONDITIONS OF THIS HOME:
Page 5
Dr. Samir A. Runja. (2019). quotations on juvenile by supreme court of india juvenile justice (care and protection of children) act, 2015. International Education and Research Journal (IERJ), 5(8). Retrieved from http://ierj.in/journal/index.php/ierj/article/view/1864
Chandrakant S. P. (2008). Child in India. Indian journal of psychiatry, 50(2), 85–86. https://doi.org/10.4103/0019-5545.42393
Marpna, I. (2017). A Study on the causes of Juvenile Delinquency in Shillong. Dissertation for Master of Social Work. Assam Don Bosco University. Sonapur, Assam. https://ijip.in/wp-content/uploads/2021/01/18.01.138.20200804.pdf
National Crime Records Bureau (NCRB).Crime in India 2020.The Ministry of Home Affairs. https://ncrb.gov.in/en/Crime-in-India-2020
https://www.hindustantimes.com/india/40-of-juvenile-delinquents-in-homes-worse-than-jails-sc/story-CaWUMuIS7VZrqTqWovpB8J.html
Pushpender & Sabharwal , D. (2023). Juvenile Delinquency in India: A Sociological study. IOSR Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences. https://www.iosrjournals.org/iosr-jhss/papers/Vol.28-Issue6/Ser-9/A2806090109.pdf
Bhardwaj, Ramesh Kumar & Neeraj. (2021). Juvenile Delinquency in India: A Study, journal of Research in Humanities and Social Science. Vol., 9 (11), pp: 69-76. https://www.researchgate.net/publication/366249603_juvenile
Jayabharath,J & Udayavani,V (2018).International Journal of Pure and Applied Mathematics,120 (5), 2881-2892. https://acadpubl.eu/hub/2018-120-5/3/241.pdf
Mittal, Kunjana. (2015). Juvenile Delinquency in India. https://www.researchgate.net.publication/342734513
Page 6
Nirbhaya’s case was a shock to the Indian society as well as a wakeup call to the judicial system in India. As a result, the justice system of India implemented new laws to tackle heinous crimes done by juveniles in India. If you examine the crime, the most dreadful act to Nirbhaya was done by a 17 year old juvenile who later on was set free after a few years of imprisonment which sparked fury among people across the country.
The Juvenile Justice Act of 1986 was devised to offer care, rehabilitation, protection, mental health treatment, and cognitive skill development for juvenile delinquents. In line with these goals, both government and private NGOs have established correctional facilities. Juveniles arrested for crimes are typically placed in these centers following a legal review. However, these facilities often fail to address the root causes of delinquency, focusing instead on the crime itself and applying a generic approach common worldwide for punitive measures.
In India, juveniles are categorized as either “Child In Need Of Care And Protection” or “Children In Conflict With Law,” both under 18 years old. Those in conflict with the law require correctional interventions to ensure a safer future. These facilities aim to hold youth accountable, meet court verdicts, and provide rehabilitative support to prevent reoffending. [19]
Despite robust laws, there is a lack of necessary infrastructure and effective action plans. Even with well-trained counselors and psychiatrists, both government and private facilities struggle to achieve optimal results due to various challenges. This paper evaluates current practices, methods, and laws related to juvenile delinquents.
Being a part of society has become a mandatory thing to exist in the modern era. Apart from the oneness and warmth it provides there are certain unwritten laws that have to be abided by the people who are a part of it. Any obstruction in the confined set of rules can cause tension, discomfort, trauma to the people who dwell. When a child is the main reason for such issues they are called delinquent. Delinquents often try to mimic adults in doing crime and they commit themselves to ill doing. Hormonal and influential factors play a cardinal role in driving them to crime. It’s not possible or even practical to keep a child away from such factors. However, righteousness can be imparted to them by parents or people who are close to them. Lack of such factors is the main issue of juvenile delinquency [21].
Juveniles are now indulging in heinous crimes like rape, murder, dacoity, theft, robbery. There can be numerous reasons for them to think and later act twisted. However, we can broadly classify them as biological and environmental causes. If we go into details the reason can be explained as follows:
Lower intelligence, mental health issues, physical disabilities, inadequate education, parental problems, and past trauma can lead to violent, impulsive behaviors in individuals. Studies show that delinquents generally have lower intelligence, academic performance, and school attendance, with poor early cognitive development linked to delinquency and potential uncontrollable aggression [22][23].
Neglect is a primary factor in juvenile delinquency. Issues like parental neglect, abuse, divorce, and a dysfunctional environment can lead to frustration, which delinquents often express through their behavior. Offenses result from various individual and external factors, including parental neglect, peer pressure, and poor financial conditions [10].
Be it any sort of crime, money acquires the major share as a motivation factor and same is the story of Juvenile Delinquents. And also, there is a flip side to the issue: Many Indian parents do not have time to care for their children as they are equipped in running behind money. Children often feel left behind and they seek attention from outside which lands them in trouble [24].
Page 7
ENVIRONMENTAL FACTORS:
Environmental factors, including a child’s surroundings and peer pressure, significantly influence juvenile delinquency. Studies show that family structure and the child’s environment play crucial roles in delinquency, emphasizing the need for community attention to prevent such issues. [25, 26, and 27]
Children today are trapped by the drug mafia, becoming addicted to harmful drugs at a young age. Substance abuse is closely linked to criminal behavior, with increased drug use leading to more severe violence and crime. Rising juvenile offenses like rape, murder, and burglary are often associated with drug use, such as cannabis with murder, inhalants with rape, and opioids with snatching crimes. [28].
Urbanization and its spread are beyond imagination. Even though the merits are in plenty, there are demerits that can’t be avoided. The conflict of being pushed away has brought in cultural conflicts in the youngling and they mainly express it through aggression
A recent study by Asian Centre for Human Rights (ACHR) [29] has revealed that 11 out of 39 juvenile cases are reported from government-run juvenile justice homes and the rest from NGO-run private organizations. So something is fundamentally wrong with these correctional facilities.
ISSUES WITH JUVENILE CORRECTIONAL FACILITIES:
SUGGESTIONS TO IMPROVE CONDITIONS IN FAMILY AND INSTITUTIONS:
CONCLUSION:
PREVENTION IS BETTER THAN CURE:
Even after establishing these many correctional setups there is something lagging in these facilities that contribute to the increased crime rate as well as recidivism rate among juveniles. If we take into consideration the crime rate of juvenile according to the report of NCRB “CRIME IN INDIA 2020”, [4] it shows that as of December 31, 2020, the largest proportion of inmates (215,418 individuals, accounting for 44.1%) fell within the age range of 18-30 years. The next significant age group was 30-50 years, comprising 209,400 inmates (42.9%), while 63,687 individuals (13.0%) were above the age of 50. The age group of 16-18 years had only six inmates. Out of the 82,353 convicts admitted in the year 2020, 3,908 (constituting 4.7% of the admitted convicts) were identified as habitual offenders.
It is startling that juveniles living with their parents (3,588) commit more crimes than homeless children (85). Additionally, many juvenile offenders have at least a basic education. This questions the standard of family and educational systems in fostering positive moral development. These statistics suggest that correctional facilities mainly address recidivism rather than preventing crime. Effective prevention of juvenile delinquency can safeguard young lives, avoid future criminal behavior, and reduce societal crime burdens. Thus, a comprehensive approach involving family and education is crucial for effective correction. There is a saying, ‘WHAT YOU SOW, SO YOU REAP’ and it is much true in case of juveniles where we as a family, society and institutions are responsible for sowing morality and good things in young minds.
Change doesn’t happen over a fortnight! It’s a slow process however, if it creates a better tomorrow for children of India. It has to be given utmost importance since they are the future of any country. Necessary intervention by government and NGOs should be facilitated so that reformed juveniles can adapt better into society
Formal and informal social networks must work hand-to-hand to make it happen. Most importantly, after care should be innovative and should not be in a way that would make the juvenile feel that they are being constricted.
REFERENCES: